Sunday, August 9, 2020

Rhythm and Tenor




April 26.

This morning I woke up around 4 a.m. 

At this hour of the morning, birds do not sing.

There’s a stillness that comes of the night. There is more stillness in it than the day; and in this can be profit. One can always learn from a deeper stillness; it calls the soul in a way that the affairs of the day do not. In abbeys, it used to be a common practice to awake in the middle of the night, say 2 am or 3 am,  and engage in common prayer. 

There’s something to be said for a sacred act engaged in while the rest of the world is silent. 

Each day ought to have a few moments where there is time set aside to just take one's life in quite simply, without the accessories of thought and concern. In this way one can learn without complications how to sit and sense the pulse of one’s life, the rhythm and tenor of it, before the pressures of time and embellishments of personality arrive. 

There’s someone here who is of the essence. My personage in its most purified and refined form. 

That form has a contact with the highest source of life. In Christianity, we call it the soul; the Buddhists call it Buddha nature. It’s always here within us, like the sweet and nourishing kernel of a nut. However one wants to characterize it, it has an unmistakable flavor that isn’t touched by the world, but lives in it and receives it.

The word tenor originally comes from the Latin tenere. It was used to denote import or meaning, as, for example, in a law. So sensing the tenor of our life is to sense its meaning. As I have oft explained, that meaning already begins before I have any meanings in me. My own meanings are invented meanings. The true meaning of life is, in the biblical phrase, begotten, not made. That is to say, it’s the product of a birth which is generated by a sacred action, and not a product of my ability to reason and fashion things.

The word rhythm is from the Latin rhythmus, which is related to a root that originally meant, in a general sense, to flow. The Oxford English Dictionary defines it, in musical terms, as the analysis of a piece according to the duration and arrangement of the notes.

What I want to point at here is the difference between rhythm and tenor. Rhythm is most distinctly of time. The flow of events is time. Tenor is metaphysical; it lies outside time. The meaning in our life may be expressed in time, but in the end it’s just as unspoken and mysterious as the effect of music. Music is a language we understand with parts of ourselves that don’t use words. Like meaning, it’s born of time; and it brings a wordless meaning into us that can bring joy or sadness, without words. It connects with this part of ourselves called the soul, and reminds us that it has capacities beyond our thought.

When I begin in the morning and I sense the pulse of this life, I’m interested in quietly coming to the duration and tone of life as it arises between time and eternity. The rhythm of my life is of time and in time; but the tenor is of eternity, of that which lies outside time. 

Both those forces meet together in Being: the worlds of time, and the meanings of eternity.

These two ideas, from an intellectual and metaphysical point of view, are huge. Incomprehensible. In fact, although we could engage in long intellectual discussions about them, there’s no need. The point that I'm making is that we can sense and understand the conjunction of these two sets of metaphysical forces quite simply within our Being. There is a part of us which is a genius that does this quite easily. I just need to listen for it. 

There’s an echo of it even now.

Now, there ought to be a rule somewhere – especially for me —not to give more than two examples of etymology in a single essay. It would be especially good to have this rule because then occasionally I could break it. 

The word genius comes from the Latin and means “the attendant spirit present from one's birth.” In this sense it's exactly the right word, because the genius in us is our essence, that part of the soul that touches God (See Meister Eckhart, sermon 52.) It’s already there before time. 

It’s there before I think of it. (In fact I ought to stop thinking about it!)

And in this great silence from which the world emerges, the resonance and consonance of its vibration sounds an eternal tone, one that comes from outside time. That single note of Being is where life begins – all of it. We’re as much carriers and sensors of it as the birds that sing. 

If we listen carefully, perhaps we begin to understand that birdsong is as close to the soul as God; and although it comes from the world, it speaks to the other side of it in this unknown language.

I'm tempted to say more, but I'll leave it there for this morning.

Go. and sense, and be well.












Lee



Lee van Laer is a Senior Editor at Parabola Magazine.

Thursday, August 6, 2020

Without Interference


April 25

I got up late at 5:40 AM this morning. There’s a dense fog in the Sparkill hollow this morning. 

As I sit here, my imagination creates a range of situations that don't actually exist. I examine them one by one, as if each one was real. A lot of that goes on during the day and I don't pay much attention to it, so it's interesting to catch it early in the morning and see how it doesn't actually relate to any reality I currently inhabit. It mostly consists of lists of attitudes – or potential attitudes that I may end up infected with later during the day – random ideas, and things that will probably happen, although there’s no guarantee.

What has actually happened so far this morning – no plan, mind you, just the arising of the natural state—is that I read a bit of news. I try to avoid reading too much—I find most news toxic, and so I try to limit my dose to a single tablespoon of crap in the morning. Call it a form of self-punishment for choosing to be reincarnated in this mess we’re all in. After the daily dose, I  reviewed some PDFs recently added to my library, and went over a page of master jazz chord forms for guitar which my BFF Steve sent me. (Thanks, Steve.) I'm discovering that playing guitar is good exercise for the arthritis in my hands. Finally, guitar playing has a practical purpose. I always knew it would someday.

I've also been going through my physical library of books over the past few days, on the way marveling (and this is far from the first time) at the vast amount of material we humans produce to explain everything. It’s as though God, when He was creating the universe, at one point scratched His beard and said to Himself, “Holy Crap! What does all this mean? I should figure that out… no, forget that. It’s waaaay too complicated and would literally take forever… I know. I’ll delegate it. Just create a creature that will do it for me…” and with the least gesture of His little finger, there we were and here we are. 

Churning out an endless series of explanations for everything. 

Anyone who sets out to explain anything comes to find that explanation is a self replicating disease, exactly like a virus –the first explanation inserts its RNA into the DNA of the natural state, takes over, replicates, and spreads a million copies of itself in every direction, each one of which consists of yet another explanation. They go on to infect more objects, events, circumstances, and conditions, in a wild free-for-all. During the process, the explanations mutate; they create new forms that are either more or less infectious. There are no vaccines. Eventually, with we humans, sanity ends up on a ventilator without an attendant.

What is on my mind, however, is not all the explanations, but a particular one of them. 

We inhabit a natural state that arises naturally. Everything within us and outside of us arises quite naturally, without interference. It doesn't need our explanations; even though those are also a postpartum aspect of the natural state. 

If we step back from our identification with the natural state (identification being the condition in which we think we are the natural state, or, equally incorrect, that it belongs to us in one way or another) it's possible to inhabit it without all this interference.

This is a tricky thing, because interference is in our nature. The example I gave of my imagination this morning is all about interference. 

There’s a stillness, what I call the silence at the heart of being, that arises at the root of our organic sensation. The natural state is effortlessly embedded in that stillness. My whole being is an instantaneous and simultaneous expression of that natural state and that stillness. It's entirely available; but the instant I interfere, confusion arises.

There’s nothing confusing in stillness and silence. There’s nothing confusing in being quiet and waiting for life to be here with me. I don't have to invent it in my imagination; it's already here with me. It can speak in its own language and provide its own impetus if I let it. There just needs to be an emptiness that makes room for it.

This point was well made by both Meister Eckhart in his final words, and by Brother Lawrence in The Practice of the Presence of God. (I can’t overemphasize the unique value of these two resources for acquiring a simple conceptual understanding of Being.) It points to the question of presence—the subject of the latest issue of Parabola, which you can review at Parabola.org—and its role in living.

In his masterpiece The Shobogenzo (another great resource, but a bit more difficult), Zen Master Dogen said, 

It is difficult to put oars into the hands of a mountaineer, nevertheless, I must bestow the teaching.

—Bendowa, Chapter one

Folks offer many explanations of presence; but it's not that complicated. 

It’s what’s there when I don't interfere. 

It doesn’t help climb mountains; it helps one find one’s seat in the rowboat.

Go. and sense, and be well.












Lee



Lee van Laer is a Senior Editor at Parabola Magazine.

Monday, August 3, 2020

The Poetry of Stone



April 24

This morning, a light rain is falling. It will become heavier later. It's still dark; and the birds are singing in a melodious but deceivingly disorganized manner. After all, to each of them, their birdsong is purposeful; yet because of their multiple intentions and species, there’s a rhythymic and melodic disunity.

I say it’s deceivingly disorganized because within me, it becomes a whole thing nonetheless. Although the intelligence hears the disorder, the feelings have the capacity to blend it into a single and pleasing whole that lends a sense of beauty to the morning. Without the feelings, this wouldn't happen.

This morning, I climbed up the stairs after getting coffee, as I do every morning. The stairs, like the house, are nearly 100 years old. Their creaks have informed many an early morning aside from my own. Like the birdsong and the rain, they’re reminders that I inhabit a continuity. I don't own any of these things. I receive their impressions.

There's a piece of bluestone here on my desk which I cut down to a rectangle of the right size to prop up my iPad at a slightly sharper angle. That stone is made from ancient layers of sandstone; yet despite its venerable history, by itself it seems generally uninteresting. Just a piece of rock.

The shape, however, and the color, have qualities that only this piece of stone can have. This morning I was struck – as I still am, looking at it – by the way the feelings receive it. It has a sacred quality to it, a quality of existence that mere seeing with the eyes or thinking with the mind can't conceive of. Both of those acts of perception have a literalism to them that cannot comprehend the feeling, the poetry of this piece of stone.

I say poetry, because the word itself means the creative use of literature, especially to convey feeling. Poetry takes words and somehow makes more of them than what they are by opening a psycho-spiritual space into which feeling can enter. To take something literally means to take words in their usual or most basic sense without metaphor or allegory; to be poetic means to add more: not with more words, but with an invitation to feeling.

We don't know quite what feeling is — of course, it’s a perception, but of a refined nature that defies exact description with words. Yet we know quite clearly when we have it; and it imparts a quality to life without which life would be flat and essentially meaningless. “Play it with feeling,” the piano teacher says to their music pupil. It gives the impulse to everything we do: "I don't feel like it" shuts things down.

Yet what do I feel like? There are times when the inner landscape of feeling seems flat and without features. I hit a point like that last night just before dinner, after working on a song for an hour and a half without getting very far. The landscape was suddenly blank.

Fortunately, I'm not unfamiliar with moments like this, and instead of allowing it to become self-inflected in a feedback loop that leads, all too often, to a subtle but growing depression, I ignored it. It gradually subsided and my feeling re-populated the inner landscape with an appropriate and more sensitive response to this ordinary nature of life.

No one would argue that feeling has levels of refinement; yet we all too often invest that level of refinement in its products, such as music, fine oil paintings, expressive dance, an exceptionally well made piece of fabric. In doing so, we don't adequately scrutinize the way the feelings are within us--not in the objects--as part of our intelligence and understanding.

I don't use the word intelligence as a reference to intellect, the part that classifies and organizes and discriminates. The example I gave of the disorganized yet still beautiful birdsong shows the limits of the intellect. Only the feeling can blend the birds into beauty. It opens a window on the sacred. The sacred is, in religious terms, what is holy; and that in turn means what is whole. Feeling helps bring a wholeness to life.

A feature of our psyche this important might, you think, deserve a bit more attention than we give it. Our usual interaction with feeling is to take it for granted, rather than taking a close look at the way it acts within us on small things. Yet most of the food we need in our daily life to support ourselves emotionally comes from our feeling-relationship with the small events that surround us. Anyone knows that having a bunch of annoying little things go wrong will put you in a bad mood; and it's equally true many pleasing little things that go right put us in a good one. It reminds me of a quote that a friend offered me the other night from the architect Ludwig Mies van Der Rohe: “God is in the details.”

“Yes,” I reminded him, “But the devil’s in there too.”

The idea that both God and the devil live together within the details is an interesting one to me. It puts the sacred and the profane together in one place. It’s the action of feeling that discriminates between them.

I'm curious about this because so much of the satisfying meaning in life seems to be about developing a healthy feeling-relationship with the least of things. In each day, if I attend mindfully to the little things, the big ones generally take care of themselves. Early on in my education in inner spiritual work, my teacher gave me sensitively intelligent indications about that; and I had no real idea of their value. It's only now, nearly 40 years later, that it makes sense. And it makes sense in such small ways, such intimate ways, that I wonder how it could be so easily overlooked.

It’s as though in our rush to get to life, we always race past it.

That brings me back to the collective theme of my diary for this month, which is to cultivate an inner stillness—from which I stop racing, and begin to feel my life, instead of thinking about it.

Maybe where I am is acceptable.

Go. and sense, and be well.












Lee



Lee van Laer is a Senior Editor at Parabola Magazine.

Friday, July 31, 2020

The Simple Action of Awareness


Yesterday I cleaned up my office. I've been working in it at home for over a month and some of the shelves that housed my very eclectic victorian-style collection of artifacts and natural history specimens were too dusty to ignore any more.

I had to take over 100 small objects off two shelves and clean them. They have been collected over the course of a lifetime: fossils, crystals, small figurines made of stone and wood and ceramic, antique Japanese ivory carvings inherited from the Dutch side of the family. 19th century daguerreotypes of family members on my mother’s side, who can no longer be named with any confidence. Chinese plates. Delft plates. Spodumene, emerald, amethyst. Rutile from Graves Mountain, GA. Herkimer diamonds. Arrowheads, trilobites, spirifers, Devonian clams. Feathers, skulls, coral; bits and pieces of dinosaurs and opossums. Flotsam. Jetsam. Religious statues. Bronzes.

Each one of these items has a personal history behind it. Not one of them has a personal history that truly begins with me. I’ve just become a custodian for each of these objects. Taken together, they tell a story, but it’s incredibly complicated. It’s not a story not about me and my interests, but about the world and how it develops: the relationships between atoms, molecules, cells, evolution, art, science, religion, families, cultures, and attitudes. The dialogue that takes place between them involves materials, symbols, space, shape, color, beauty, and history.

Collectively, all of this is what's called meaning: and in the search for meaning within an individual life, a collection of this nature externally illustrates the way we are inside. Every one of the concepts and things I’ve just described emerges not from the inherent nature of these objects, but the awareness that perceives them. In this sense, all meaning arises within awareness: and awareness is a metaphysical, not physical, property. It arises out of an impossibly complex set of relationships that can never—never, ever—be defined or predicted by a computer algorithm. Yet the simple action of awareness holds them all together, in active relationship, at once, and with no effort.

Perhaps it seems odd that everything about the world is formed by a phenomenon of awareness that exceeds the world. Yet this is demonstrably true. No one can take awareness and put it in a bottle and show it to you; it is metaphysical in every sense of the word. So although I inhabit the physical, am formed by it, and have to pay it it's due, it is not what I am.

“I am” is something else.

Every morning I get up and I discover all over again that I don't know what or who I am. If I come up with 10,000 definitions, it turns out that definition 10,001 was inadvertently left out later on in the day. My assumptions about myself and life are continually confounded. Things that I thought worth fear turn out to not be worth fearing; people I’m angry or irritated with turn out to not be worth my anger or irritation. For that matter, all too often, my anger and irritation turns out to not be worth itself. There’s more goodness and intelligence in seeing a sparrow than in my reaction to a lot of things. So my reactions aren’t worth that much either. During this day I’ll probably see that a few times and invest less in them, keeping the coin of my person closer to myself, for down payment on more worthy inner tasks.

Yesterday, I mentioned the silence at the heart of being, and that’s where I began this morning, not knowing what I would write or which question I would examine. It turns out that that is, as usual, the central question, no matter how much the ideas and words around it may shine out of the darkness.

 That silence at the heart of being is where awareness resides.

In my desire, I want to fulfill the potential of each moment.

But if I’m still and wait within myself and receive life, the potential of the moment is naturally filled.


Go. and sense, and be well.












Lee



Lee van Laer is a Senior Editor at Parabola Magazine.

Monday, July 27, 2020

The Medium of Being


Spring beauties, Piermont, NY.

April 23.

We arise and are created as Self; and we meet life, which is not-self.

The experience of life—the conjunction between self and not-self— consists of impressions. 

Impressions are what is pressed into us; that is, they leave a mark. The mark that they leave is, put in general terms, in our psyche; yet our psyche is not just one aspect of sensory experience. It is made of three different kinds of experience: the physical experience of sensation, the psychological experience of the intellect, and the emotional experience of feeling.

In the arts, what makes or receives a mark is called a medium. Dust, ink and paper or oil and canvas are mediums.

If the medium that I receive my life and the impressions of it in is my intellect, my thought, the medium is ephemeral and fleeting. It doesn't have the substance to receive an impression and record the mark deeply in Being. 

Perhaps this one observation alone can instruct us on why we don't work; nothing in us becomes permanent enough to sustain its action.

If, however, the medium that I receive my life in is sensation, the body, it leaves a much deeper mark. 

The medium that being grows in is sensation. 

This is why the Vedic sage Kasyapa ordered his verses about three-centered work (see the post of July 24) beginning with the work of the three centers, and focusing on sensation first (inward breath—outward breath—diffusive breath.)


I could belabor this point, but I think it’s simple enough.

Go. and sense, and be well.












Lee



Lee van Laer is a Senior Editor at Parabola Magazine.

Friday, July 24, 2020

Shhhh...



I've always discovered a terrific irony in speaking about silence. Not that I'm much of a pioneer; the irony comes built-in. All I do is remark on it to myself. Yet there it is. 

It's a ploy of spiritual seekers, especially ones who think they have some kind of authority, to remind others un-silently of how they should remain silent about this or that, or remain silent in general. Another typical stance is to solemnly sit with one another and declare out loud how important silence is and how earnestly one is seeking it. There is, in other words, a furtive dishonesty around the whole enterprise of discussing silence which simply has to be listened to to be believed.

I make no apologies for discussing the subject; it is not off-limits, nor should it be avoided. Or used as a means of scolding people for their practice.

Is silence the mere absence of sound? Not quite; because, it turns out in esoteric disciplines, that silence means not just the absence of sound, but specifically, the absence of sounds that might reveal some special secret or make something too obvious; sounds that are considered crude and inappropriate, and so on. In every sense, in other words, the word sound – and the word silence – are taken quite literally. This in the sense that they refer to physical sounds, sounds we can hear with our ears, sounds that form ideas and convey meanings.

This is not the kind of sound or silence I wish to speak of. There is a metaphysical silence; and this silence is not tied to the worldly, earthly, or conventional understandings we have of silence. Not at all. It refers, instead, to a silence that takes place inside being, but outside the world of physics – and a listening that takes place not with the ears or the thoughts that follow them, but with a finally tuned attention that arises in sensation and turns toward feeling.

One can undertake a search for the silence that is naturally present behind all else using these faculties. The organism is designed to come in to an intimate relationship with that silence. That silence, furthermore, lies at the root of creation and can never be removed from creation, in any sense, from any place, at any time.

It is always with us.

Human life obscures this silence. Without a sense of presents, the silence disappears – it’s absorbed into the background simply because it is silent. We only pay attention, it seems, to things that make noise of one kind or another. 

Yet it's entirely possible to have an attention to silence at the same time everything is going on around me. This attention depends on my connection to organic sensation; the moment that that connection becomes active, the silence is present within. Everything else in life becomes an argument; the silence is a fact. It has a capacity to receive everything that takes place without being disturbed. 

On this note, let’s examine a quote from Kasyapa in the Vedic hymns:

I am undisturbed, and undisturbed my soul,
undisturbed my eyes and ears 
undisturbed my inward breath, my outward breath
undisturbed my breath within—undisturbed the whole of me.
— Atharvaveda, Book XIX

Of importance here is the residence in silence, which is what the word undisturbed refers to. It merits a whole verse of its own.

The fourth line, which mentions the breath within, is also translated as the "diffusive" breath. This is a reference to the act of organic sensation, which is fed by finer substances inhaled. While this may be obscure to the uninitiated, it is indubitably so. 

This verse, furthermore, refers to the first center: the physical body.

This capacity for silence is essential, because the place in which it receives life—which is the subject of the next verse in the Veda—is what feeds Being:

Thereafter rose Desire in the beginning, Desire the primal seed and germ of Spirit,
O Kama (wish) dwelling with the lofty Kama (higher wish), give growth of riches to the sacrificer, (...)
Prolific, thousand eyed, and undecaying, a horse with seven reins Time bears us onward,
Sages inspired with holy knowledge mount him, his chariot wheels are all the worlds of creatures.

This verse refers to the second and third centers: 
  • Emotion (desire and Kama) is a horse with seven reins (a reference to the law of octaves)
  • Intelligence (sages with holy knowledge mount him.) 

So in this Veda, it teaches that what begins in the silence of the body lays the foundation for three-centered work. It mentions that feeling (desire) is what gives birth to the soul (the germ of spirit) and that wealth is gained through suffering (growth of riches to the sacrificer.) 

What moves Being forward through life is all the worlds of creatures, that is, his chariot wheels. This is, in other words, an allegorical call to work in life — which begins undisturbed, in silence.

What is most important about this teaching is its emphasis on what is undisturbed –everything, basically, that begins within Being. This is a reference to that selfsame silence that is present behind all else.


May your heart be close to God, 
and God close to your heart.















Lee



Lee van Laer is a Senior Editor at Parabola Magazine.

Tuesday, July 21, 2020

Disobedience and Its Folly


A lot of one’s inner work turns out, for one reason or another, to be a struggle with one's self over parts one perceives as being disobedient. 

Nonconforming. 

This has, as it happens, a great deal to do with the passage from Beelzebub’s Tales as quoted in the last post. 

Keep my simplified translation in mind:

…no matter who they are, if people are able, in the midst of all external circumstances, whether favorable or unfavorable, to weigh the collision between their expectations and what actually happens, they can correctly evaluate how important they are, and what their place in the world is.  

The question of obedience, of what conforms and what does not, rises precisely in this collision between our expectations and what actually happens. We expect ourselves to be good, then discover we aren't; or we expect the world to be good, and then it isn't. Of course, the converse is true as well in both cases. That is not the point. The point, as Gurdjieff draws our attention to it, is that we have a set of expectations in the first place; the world collides with it – inevitably, because the world has, in objective measurement, precisely zero to do with our expectations—and then we find out.

Er, what do we find out? 

Precisely that. That the world has nothing to do with our expectations.

Yet our ego and most of our life is formed in a very hardened and rigid kernel around our expectations. Gurdjieff suggests that we ponder how important we are and what our place in the world is according to the weight of our observations—our objective observations—about what is. 

In the end, it adds up in simple English to an act of seeing our own nothingness.

Perhaps it shouldn't surprise readers that we find out that in the end, Gurdjieff used 145 words to say, in what I’m pretty sure is the most very complicated way possible, that we should see our own nothingness 

– four words. 

In the last essay, we reduced Gurdjieff's excess verbiage by a lightweight 60%. In these four words, seeing our own nothingness, one has actually removed 97% of his single-sentence paragraph and thereby reduced it to an adage famous in his work. If that trend is extrapolated, it turns out the book has the potential to be only 34 pages long. 

Worth pondering.

All humor aside, I actually intend to make a point about obedience. The dilemma in front of us is whether to obey our own ego, or obey the facts about the world. Despite the insistent perspective of my all-controlling ego, I actually have no control over the disobedient world—or my disobedient parts. 

Yet both inwardly and outwardly I too often find myself in a pitched battle with one, or both of them, same time. This is a battle I'm not going to win.

As I suggested to someone recently, a more productive approach might be as follows: 

Don't focus on what is disobedient and resist it. 
Find what is obedient and train it.


Not all of us is in rebellion. We can perhaps work more productively with what is, rather than what isn't.


May your heart be close to God, 
and God close to your heart.















Lee



Lee van Laer is a Senior Editor at Parabola Magazine.

Saturday, July 18, 2020

Pondering pondering


Detail from the Tympanum of St. Foy, in Conques. 
A devil and an angel weigh a soul.

Likewise, an all-round awareness of everything concerning these sacred laws also conduces, in general, to this, that three-brained beings irrespective of the form of their exterior coating, by becoming capable in the presence of all cosmic factors not depending on them and arising round about them—both the personally favorable as well as the unfavorable—of pondering on the sense of existence, acquire data for the elucidation and reconciliation in themselves of that, what is called, ‘individual collision’ which often arises, in general, in three-brained beings from the contradiction between the concrete results flowing from the processes of all the cosmic laws and the results presupposed and even quite surely expected by their what is called ‘sane-logic’; and thus, correctly evaluating the essential significance of their own presence, they become capable of becoming aware of the genuine corresponding place for themselves in these common-cosmic actualizations.

Beelzebub’s Tales to His Grandson, pages 756-57, 1950 edition.

Gurdjieff’s magnum opus has acquired the dubious status of a Bible among most Gurdjieff aficionados; criticizing it is a moribund art in those circles, and – let's face it – most other circles simply ignore the book, which is a silent but perhaps more pointed form of criticism.

The book, like the works of James Fenimore Cooper – which in no way whatsoever ought ever to be compared with Gurdjieff’s writing, other than the one you are about to hear –finds itself guilty as charged of Mark Twain's criticism of Cooper, to wit, “he never uses one word where 50 will do.” The above sentence has 145 – count them, 145 – words in it. I am hoping this sets some kind of a record for any language, but I'm not sure. It's possible there may be even longer sentences in this book.

Why bring this up? Well, by the time honored-traditions of accident and serendipity. It's mostly because having recently been party to a conversation about the word pondering, a search for it in the book was called for. 

It only comes up some 25 times or so throughout the entire course of the novel, which is not a lot, but the word has acquired a good deal of weight in Gurdjieff circles. This is perhaps rightly so, and entirely appropriate — the word, after all, is derived from the Latin root -pondus which refers to weight.

To ponder is not just to think over, which is what the word means today. It means to deliberate—which, not coincidentally, also refers to weight in its Latin origins, -de, meaning down, and librare, from Libra, or scales. 

Ahem—since I speak as a Libra, I think we can all agree I’m uniquely qualified to comment on this. Amen.

The point of pondering is not just to think. 

It is to weigh, which is a physical action, involving an impression and sensation of the way that gravity affects comparable objects. Furthermore, it is not just to weigh, but to thereby discriminate, to distinguish between.

Pondering, in other words, involves having a physical sensation of a question, not just a mental one, and using the impression that that conveys in order to make a choice between the two. The element of choice is essential in the act of pondering, because there is no point in weighing and comparing things unless the aim is to first understand the difference; and to then choose one or the other.

This ties the action of true inward discrimination to the question of the gravity of sensation of Being. And, as I explained to someone the other night, if we have a sensation of Being, it changes our thinking a very great deal. Without sensation, thinking is not tethered down. It floats around like a balloon, affected by every breeze that comes along. As soon as sensation enters the picture, thinking assumes a subservient position. With gravity in place, it becomes relatively motionless and prepared to receive what arrives. The more organic sensation, the more this is true.

Just as a public service, I’m going to engage in sacrilege and translate Gurdjieff’s paragraph into something simpler:

A complete awareness of these sacred laws also helps in this: no matter who they are, if people are able, in the midst of all external circumstances, whether favorable or unfavorable, to weigh the collision between their expectations and what actually happens, they can correctly evaluate how important they are, and what their place in the world is.  

This is the gist of what Gurdjieff says, with better than 60% fewer words. 

And, mind you, people call me loquacious. 

This, then, is the essence of pondering. To weigh what is within Being. Notice, furthermore, that in the same criminal run-on sentence which Gurdjieff mentions this word pondering, he points out that the result of pondering is an act of discrimination. 

One does not ponder just for the sake of pondering; one ponders in order to discriminate. Pondering, in other words, cannot be some aimless, mindless mental noodling that stumbles from one subject to another without understanding, touching on many ideas without sorting them out. 

It has a purpose—an aim—a direction. 

There's more.

Before one weighs anything, one has to decide what to weigh. One can't just throw the whole world on a set of scales at one time and sort it out. Scales are designed to accommodate two comparative objects at a time, no more. In this sense, the discrimination begins even before one ponders. It begins as the impressions enter the gravity of one’s being. First, one must just be present for that, in order to know what ought to be pondered.

Ponder that.

Readers who wish to read my monograph on the tympanum at St. Foy in Conques, which is much more fun than it sounds, may email me for a free copy.

May your heart be close to God, 
and God close to your heart.















Lee



Lee van Laer is a Senior Editor at Parabola Magazine.